Bach’s Dilemma
Perhaps the greatest piece of music ever written is Bach’s Mass in B minor. I am awed by the intricate polyphony and structural genius.
Interestingly, Bach never heard a performance of this great work. When writing the mass, Bach pandered neither to the Protestant Lutherans nor the Roman Catholics. He included liturgical elements that offended both sides. Therefore neither denomination provided a house of worship for his composition during his lifetime.
I often think about Bach when I study the theology of baptism. My personal convictions on this topic are too Catholic for the Protestants and too Protestant for the Catholics. Fortunately, in the Christian Churches I have found a place where those kinds of dilemmas are not an issue. I have found a home for my faith and a place to worship.
The reason this is not an issue in the Christian Churches is not because people do not care. It is because neither Luther nor the Pope has an authoritative voice in them. Final authority is reserved for the Word of God. If following the Scriptures means I agree with the Catholics on an issue then so be it. If it means that I agree with the Protestants on another then that is okay too.
July 21st, 2009 at 4:37 am
Could not agree more…well said